Baseball

2025: Luke Perry – Barton College

2024: Ray Shaw – Chowan University, Ethan Staton – Methodist University

2023: Tyler Winkler – Geneva College 

Basketball

2024: Tori Coleman – Methodist University, Ramsey Cureton – Fayetteville State University

2023: Faron Cureton – Thomas College, Dana Galinis – Principia College

2022: Jude Wisman-Raven – Ramapo College

2017: Sydnee Neal – Chowan University

Cross Country

2024: Cristian Waddell-Lallana – William Peace University

Football

2025: TT Moore – Lenoir-Rhyne University, Caleb Stahl – Lenoir-Rhyne University

2024: Tucker Holmes – Lawrence University

2023: Joey Koesters – Washington & Lee University, Xae Lang – Hampden-Sydney College, Rion Roseborough – Towson University & East Carolina University, Max Winkler – Grove City College

2022: Nate Hasselbach – Catholic University, Will McMinn – NC Wesleyan University

Lacrosse

2024: Will Fawcett – Methodist University, Thomas Keeter – Catawba College

2023: Nick Garza – Methodist University

Soccer

2025: Phoenix Balot – Lenoir-Rhyne University

2024: Caleb Jones – Ave Maria University

2023: Noah Bullock – Methodist University, Katherine Stanley – Virginia Military Institute

Softball

2024: Tenley Weathington – Columbia International University

Track & Field

2024: Cristian Waddell-Lallana – William Peace University

Volleyball

2025: Laci Bitterman – Cape Fear Community College

2023: Hailey Davenport – NC Wesleyan University, Dana Galinis – Principia College